“You’ve Come a Long Way, Maybe”
Posted in News & Politics on November 30th, 2009 by Morgan ElizabethAuthor Leslie Sanchez has made a name for herself as a political analyst and former presidential advisor. She’s been published in The New York Times, The Washington Post, and The Wall Street Journal, and appeared as a pundit on ABC, NBC, CNN, and Fox News, among others. [1]
Her recent book, You’ve Come a Long Way, Maybe: Sarah, Michelle, Hillary, and the Shaping of the New American Woman, studies the impact of these women on the 2008 presidential campaign.
While her analysis is interesting, it’s far from objective. By inserting heavy-handed conservative judgments at every opportunity, she alienates and mocks readers who might disagree. The book, though thoroughly researched, reads more like a long op ed piece than legitimate journalism.
The quoted passages and reference materials do offer insight to the prevalence of sexism during the race. “Rush Limbaugh, speaking of a particularly unflattering photo of Clinton, … asked: ‘Will Americans want to watch a woman get older before their eyes on a daily basis?’” Though, he claimed aging men look “more authoritative, accomplished and distinguished.” Then, discussing Palin’s appeal, he said “she’s not going to remind anybody of their ex-wife, she’s going to remind men, ‘Gee, I wish she was single.’” (p.50-51). While Limbaugh is one of the more inflammatory pundits, many others described Hillary as too cold, and Palin as “exceptionally pretty,” and “a real honey.” (p.47) Even Michelle Obama, an accomplished lawyer and activist, had the media focus on her wardrobe and physique (particularly her arms) more than anything else.
“According to a poll of women conducted for Lifetime Networks after the 2008 election, ‘65 percent of women – majorities in every demographic and political group – said that male and female candidates are held to different standards on the campaign trail.’ Women thought it was easier for a man to be ‘taken seriously by the voters,’ or to be ‘covered seriously by the media.’” (p.125) Americans also frowned upon Palin as a working mom more than Obama as a working dad, and tended to view racism as a bigger problem than sexism.
Sanchez presents interesting points in this way, but veers into dangerous territory when revealing her biases. For one, she claims that any women who supported Hillary in the primaries, but didn’t switch teams to vote for Palin, were anti-feminist. “[My feminist friends] assumed that, as a career woman, I would be naturally offended by certain of the governor’s policy convictions. I was dumbfounded, and I turned the question around on them. ‘How could you not support Palin?’ … Didn’t the ’sisterhood’ mean anything to them?” (p.78) This superficial standpoint emphasizes only the biological similarities between the candidates, ignoring the fact that Clinton and Palin are political and ideological opposites.
The patronization and sexualization of women headed toward the White House was phenomenal last year, and You’ve Come a Long Way, Maybe couples valid arguments with revealing research. Still, Sanchez’s overt conservatism blurs the line between fact and opinion, and her casual, inconsistent writing style leaves much to be desired.
Sources:
[1] Leslie Sanchez Official Site: About Leslie Sanchez
[2] Sanchez, Leslie. You’ve Come a Long Way, Maybe: Sarah, Michelle, Hillary and the Shaping of the New American Woman. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2009.
